Skip to main content


Is this mind permanent, or temporary?

Is this mind permanent, or temporary? – Yoga Vasishta Answers

In one aspect, it is permanent and in the other, it is temporary. What is this 'permanent and temporary'?

A wall casts shadow in daytime. There is no shadow during the nighttime. Next day also the shadow is there. You said, "This is the shadow of our wall". The shadow of yesterday has gone yesterday itself. Then why do you speak as if this shadow and that shadow are one and the same? If they are one, then the shadow is permanent and if they are different, then, the shadow is temporary.

You are seeing your image in the mirror. The mirror is pushed aside. Then the image disappears. You brought the mirror in front of you. Again the image reappears. Now, do you say that the previous image and the present image are one or not? If you say that it is one, then, the image becomes permanent.

If you disagree, the image becomes temporary. But, when you disagree, you should show the difference.

Our mind is also similar to this. It is present now and is working. In the state of deep sleep, it is merged or absorbed. After you awoke, it starts functioning.

Now, the mind before sleep and the mind after you awoke, are they one or different? You should say either that since the first mind is merged in the sleep; so a new mind is formed after you awoke or since in the old mind and also in the new mind, it is the pure consciousness that has extended, you should accept that both are one only.

Of these, which is true? To decide or understand this, you should know 'what is this merging or disappearing?'

Merger means getting annihilated to become a void and birth means arising of new one from the void - this is the thinking or understanding of the ignorant. Since, it is not possible to happen like that, the learned ones do not think like that. They believe that merging means disappearing. Taking birth, they believe as manifestation. I am also using these words with similar meaning.

Whether it is shadow or image or mind, it has merged means it has disappeared. It is becoming invisible. Again, taking birth means it is appearing.

Rama: O' Teacher! You are repeatedly emphasizing that this mind is born from pure consciousness. In other words, this pure consciousness has created this mind. There cannot be creation without mind.

Thus before this mind is born, the pure consciousness should possess another mind. But to say that mind is present before mind is not probable or consistent. It is also impossible or inconsistent to say that the pure consciousness did this creation without the mind. How to solve this riddle?

Vasishta: Rama! There is also another riddle like this. I will tell you that. Suppose, that this mind is not born from Brahma. Then, it should have been born from void only. This is not probable. On the other hand, suppose that this mind is born from Brahma, and then it amounts to say that Brahma is with action. This is also improbable. So, how to solve this riddle?

Rama! If you follow the Upanishads sincerely, we will not encounter riddles like this. The proposed theory of Upanishads is as follows: illusion or maya is enveloping Parabrahma, the real form of pure consciousness. This illusion is distinct from Sadasat (existent non-existent). From this union, this mind is born. This is the theory.

Since illusion is distinct from Sadasat (existent - non-existent), there will not be any doubts regarding its origin etc. since, this mind is being created from the combination of Brahma and illusion, this action cannot be attributed to Brahma directly. Since Brahma is in contact with this illusion and its powers, he does not need the help of another mind. So, Rama! Understand the teachings of Upanishads properly. Then such riddles will be solved properly. Rama! You are contemplating about the creation of mind. I am also teaching the same. Here, we should not forget one thing. We are having an elaborate discussion about the formation of mind, five elements, world to arrive to the conclusion that - "there is no creation. It is all an illusion only. In fact, nothing is born or nothing is gone. It is that pure consciousness only that has pervaded everywhere". So, contemplate without forgetting this.




Read More From Hindu Blog