--> Skip to main content


Mind Can Never Be Understood by the Human Senses: A Hindu Perspective

By

Introduction

  • The mind is an enigma that has intrigued humanity since time immemorial.
  • According to Hinduism, the mind is a tool, yet it often becomes the master, creating a veil over the ultimate truth.
  • Hindu scriptures and sages emphasize that the mind, being subtle and transient, cannot be fully grasped or comprehended by human senses, which are bound by physicality.
  • Thesis: Hindu teachings suggest that the mind can be transcended but not understood by senses, as illustrated by the Bhagavad Gita, Upanishads, Ashtavakra Gita, and the wisdom of sages like Ramana Maharshi, Swami Vivekananda, and others.

The Nature of the Mind in Hindu Scriptures

  1. The Mind as Maya (Illusion):

    • Bhagavad Gita (6.5): "One must elevate, not degrade, oneself by one’s mind. The mind is the friend of the conditioned soul, and its enemy as well."
      • Mind as a dual-edged sword: friend when controlled, foe when uncontrolled.
    • Mandukya Upanishad: Describes the mind as part of the waking and dream states, transient and fleeting.
    • Tantra's view of the mind as a field of energy influenced by the interplay of Shiva (consciousness) and Shakti (energy).

  2. Mind and the Gunas (Qualities):

    • The mind operates under the influence of the three gunas: sattva (purity), rajas (activity), and tamas (inertia), as per the Bhagavad Gita (14.5).
    • Quote: "The three gunas bind the embodied soul to the mortal body."

  3. Mind as Limited and Bound:

    • Katha Upanishad (1.3.3): "The Self is not realized through the mind and senses. It can only be attained by those whom the Self chooses."
    • Suggests that the mind, being a product of prakriti (nature), cannot comprehend the infinite Self.

Stories Illustrating the Mind’s Limitations

  1. The Story of Janaka and Ashtavakra:

    • In the Ashtavakra Gita, King Janaka asks how to transcend the mind. Ashtavakra teaches: "You are not the body nor the mind; you are the witness of these."
    • This dialogue highlights the idea that the mind is an object to be observed, not the ultimate reality.

  2. Nachiketa and Yama (Katha Upanishad):

    • Nachiketa asks Yama about the nature of the Self. Yama explains that the Self is beyond sensory perception and mental grasp.
    • Yama: "The mind is like a chariot, the senses its horses, and the intellect its driver. Only by transcending this vehicle can one realize the Truth."

  3. Arjuna’s Dilemma in the Bhagavad Gita:

    • Arjuna’s confusion on the battlefield reflects the restless mind caught in rajas and tamas.
    • Krishna guides Arjuna, teaching him to transcend his mental agitation through yoga and surrender.

Sages on the Mind’s Incomprehensibility

  1. Ramakrishna Paramahamsa:

    • "The mind is like a monkey, constantly restless."
    • Ramakrishna advised surrendering to the Divine, as the mind cannot grasp the infinite.

  2. Swami Vivekananda:

    • "Mind is a fine instrument, but it must not control you."
    • Vivekananda emphasized vairagya (detachment) and abhyasa (practice) to transcend the mind’s fluctuations.

  3. Ramana Maharshi:

    • Advocated self-inquiry (Atma Vichara) to go beyond the mind: "Ask, 'Who am I?' and the mind dissolves into its source."
    • Maharshi taught that the mind cannot comprehend the Self because the Self is the very ground of all experience.

  4. Nisargadatta Maharaj:

    • "The mind creates the sense of separateness, which is an illusion."
    • His teachings stress witnessing the mind rather than identifying with it.

Modern Perspectives Rooted in Hindu Philosophy

  1. Swami Chinmayananda:

    • "The mind is a tool. Use it wisely, but know it is not you."
    • Chinmayananda’s teachings bridge ancient wisdom and modern psychology, emphasizing mindfulness and self-mastery.

  2. J. Krishnamurti:

    • Though not traditionally categorized as a Hindu sage, his teachings resonate with Advaita Vedanta: "The observer is the observed."

Practices to Transcend the Mind

  1. Meditation and Yoga:

    • Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras: "Yoga is the cessation of the modifications of the mind."
    • Techniques like pranayama, dhyana, and japa help quiet the mind and turn attention inward.

  2. Bhakti (Devotion):

    • In the Uddhava Gita, Krishna tells Uddhava that devotion can transcend the restless mind by channeling it towards the Divine.

  3. Jnana (Wisdom):

    • The Mandukya Upanishad emphasizes that realizing the non-dual Self dissolves the mind's constructs.

  4. Karma Yoga (Selfless Action):

    • Acting without attachment, as taught in the Bhagavad Gita, purifies the mind, preparing it for higher truths.
  • Hinduism’s profound teachings make it clear that the mind, being subtle and mutable, cannot be understood through human senses or intellect alone.
  • The essence of Hindu spirituality lies in transcending the mind, not attempting to master or fully comprehend it.
  • By recognizing the mind as a tool and not the ultimate reality, one can journey towards Self-realization, where the infinite truth shines beyond the grasp of the senses and intellect.
  • As Ramana Maharshi aptly puts it, "Silence is where the mind ends, and the Self begins."