--> Skip to main content

Gain And Loss, Success And Failure, Praise and Censure Originate From Man And God Has Nothing To Do With It – Wisdom Of Ancient Hindu Teachers

The wisdom of ancient Hindu teachers often revolves around understanding the nature of life and the universe, and recognizing the role of human actions and divine will in shaping our experiences. The statement "Gain and loss, success and failure, praise and censure originate from man and God has nothing to do with it" reflects a philosophical perspective found in various Hindu teachings. Here’s an exploration of this idea within the context of Hindu philosophy:

The Concept of Karma

In Hinduism, the principle of karma is central to understanding human experiences. Karma refers to the law of cause and effect, where every action has a corresponding reaction. According to this belief:

Gain and Loss: The material gains and losses one experiences are results of past actions (karma). Good actions lead to positive outcomes, while negative actions lead to adverse results.

Success and Failure: Achievements and setbacks in life are also seen as outcomes of one's past deeds. Effort (purushartha) is crucial, but the results are ultimately shaped by one's accumulated karma.

Praise and Censure: The way people perceive and react to an individual (praise or blame) is influenced by the individual's actions and behavior.

Role of Human Agency

Ancient Hindu teachers emphasize the importance of human agency in shaping one's destiny:

Self-Effort (Purushartha): Human effort and willpower are crucial in pursuing goals and overcoming obstacles. The Bhagavad Gita, for instance, encourages individuals to perform their duties with dedication and without attachment to results.

Moral Responsibility: Individuals are responsible for their actions and the ethical choices they make. This sense of responsibility underlines the importance of living a life aligned with dharma (righteousness).

Limited Divine Intervention

While Hinduism acknowledges the presence of a divine force (Brahman, Vishnu, Shiva, etc.), it also suggests that:

God as a Witness: The divine is often seen as a passive observer rather than an active intervener in the day-to-day affairs of individuals.

Divine Grace: Divine grace (kripa) can aid in overcoming karma, but it doesn't negate the necessity for personal effort and moral integrity.

Detachment and Equanimity

Another significant teaching from Hindu philosophy is the concept of detachment (vairagya) and equanimity (samata):

Detached Involvement: One should engage in actions without attachment to the outcomes. This mindset helps in maintaining peace regardless of success or failure.

Equanimity: Maintaining a balanced state of mind in praise and censure, gain and loss, is considered a sign of spiritual maturity. The Bhagavad Gita extols the virtue of equanimity, suggesting that a wise person remains undisturbed by the dualities of life.

The ancient Hindu teachers, through their emphasis on karma, self-effort, moral responsibility, and the practice of detachment, convey that human experiences are predominantly shaped by individual actions and choices. While divine grace is acknowledged, it is human agency that plays a crucial role in determining one's gains, losses, successes, and failures. This perspective encourages individuals to take responsibility for their lives and strive towards ethical and purposeful living.