In Kerala, Gods’ Own Country, whenever there is a controversy regarding faith it will somehow end up at Sabarimala Makaravilakku – the diya, or vilakku or light, that appears three times at the distant hill known as Ponnambalamedu during Makaravilakku festival which is held annually on January 14. The appearing of Makaravilakku is an open secret in Kerala, even among Ayyappa devotees. Atheists and rationalists have always maintained that it is lit by police, forest guards and temple officials. Incidentally, even when the Communists were ruling the Kerala State the Makaravilakku ritual has happened. According to Ayyappa legend, after defeating demon Mahishasura, Ayyappa merged with the Dharma Sastha murti on the Makara Jyothi day. It is believed that the tribals who were harassed by the demon Mahishasura first lit the light to celebrate the slaying of their tormentor. Another legend indicates that Ayyappa Swamy disappeared from earth at Ponnambalamedu or Kantamala where the Makaravil